In short
Hire a motion designer when the piece has to be original: a brand film, a product explainer, a title sequence, anything where the idea is the value. Use templates for the recurring graphics that appear in every video and change only in their words: lower thirds, subscribe prompts, sale banners, listing cards, end screens. A designer bills for time, and a revision is more time. A template library is a flat fee however much you make. CaliberVisual is 391 finished animations you edit in the browser, from $29 a month on Pro, with no After Effects and nothing to render on your own machine. What it cannot give you is something nobody else could have.
Two different kinds of work
Motion work splits cleanly in two. There is the piece you make once, where the concept matters and a good designer earns every hour. And there is the furniture: the name plate under a guest, the prompt to subscribe, the price on a sale post. Furniture gets made every week, and nobody has ever complimented a channel on the originality of its lower third.
Trouble starts when the two get mixed up. Paying a designer's rate to retype a guest's name is a waste of their talent and your money. Building a launch film out of stock templates gets you a launch film that looks like three other launches.
What a designer is for
Judgement. A good motion designer decides what should move and what should stay still, and that decision is most of the craft. They will give you something that belongs to you and nobody else.
The costs are real but they are not only the invoice. There is the brief, the wait, the round of feedback, the second wait. For a one-off that is fine. For something due every Thursday it is a standing meeting you did not want.
What a template library is for
Speed and sameness, which for recurring graphics are virtues. The timing and easing were worked out by somebody who does it for a living. You change the fields: text, colours, typeface, logo. The motion stays as it was made, so it is hard to make it worse.
After Effects templates from the big marketplaces give you the same head start with more control, and they are good value if you already run After Effects and know your way around a composition. If you do not, you are buying a project file and a learning curve.
The sums, roughly
Take a channel that posts weekly and wants a titled guest, a subscribe prompt and an end card in each video. That is around 150 small graphics a year. Commissioned one at a time, even cheaply, the total is a number most small channels would not approve if they saw it written down. A subscription is flat: Pro is $29 a month, Studio is $59 a month, Business is $149 a month, with no limit on exports.
The comparison flips for a single hero piece. One original thirty-second film is worth more to a brand than a year of tidy lower thirds, and no subscription will make it for you.
A sensible split
Spend designer money where people will look twice: the channel trailer, the launch, the ident. Put everything that repeats on templates and a brand kit. If you have a designer on retainer, this is also the arrangement they would choose. It keeps the dull work off their desk.
Questions
Are motion graphics templates good enough for a professional channel?
For recurring graphics, yes. Lower thirds, prompts and end cards need to be clean, on brand and consistent. Templates made by working motion designers meet that bar. Original pieces such as a trailer still justify a designer.
Do I need After Effects to use motion graphics templates?
It depends on the source. Marketplace templates are usually After Effects project files. CaliberVisual templates are edited in the browser and export MP4, GIF or MOV, so nothing needs installing.
How much does CaliberVisual cost?
Pro is $29 a month. Studio is $59 a month. Business is $149 a month. The free plan previews every animation with a watermark and opens one to edit.
Can a designer and a template library work together?
Yes, and it is the common setup. The designer makes the pieces that need an idea. The library covers the weekly graphics, styled with the same colours, typeface and logo.
